1. Working at Integrity
  2. Join our team
  3. Total rewards

Our unique corporate culture

Image of New North 2019 Workplace Excellence logo

We are proud to be the 2019 New North Workplace Excellence Award winner. This award recognizes organizations within the New North who are improving their competitive advantage through people practices that lead to successful business results. Our culture is fueled by innovation and empowerment. We inspire associates, at all levels, to bring their best ideas forward and we give them the tools to succeed.


Why do you love working at Integrity?

Here's what associates are saying about us:

Korey Klister

“What makes Integrity stand out is that all associates play a part in the company’s success. We love what we do and it shows.”

Korey Klister
Personal Lines Product Manager

Diversity & Inclusion

We value diversity & inclusion and believe it's a key driver for our associates to be collaborative, innovative and creative. The diversity of our associates, their backgrounds, experiences and individual differences are the foundation of our success. To foster an inclusive environment, we are intentional in bringing those differences together for the good of Integrity, our agency partners and customers.

“I believe in the mantra ‘You don’t build a company, you build people and they build a company.’ Our associates are what differentiates Integrity from other companies. They embrace a culture that brings out the best in us individually and collectively.”

Jill Wagner Kelly

Our core values

  1. Communicate Openly
  2. Be One Team
  3. Solve Creatively for Tomorrow
  1. Deliver Excellence
  2. Do the Right Thing

We’re always looking for great people to join our team.

Whether you’re a recent graduate or veteran professional, we look for candidates with various backgrounds at all levels of experience.

Search for open positions

Dustin Andrus

“As a growing company, there is plenty of growth and development to go around, which I can personally attest to. Being a part of Integrity and the vast opportunities it offers has been and continues to be very rewarding.”

Dustin Andrus
Commercial Lines Underwriter
Erin Janssen

Integrity offers great flexibility. The environment allows me to have work-life balance which is perfect for my young family.”

Erin Janssen
Sr. Commercial Lines Technician
Lori Klotz

“Integrity is an advocate for continuing education. It was wonderful to have everyone’s support while I earned my CPCU designation.”

Lori Klotz
Sr. Commercial Lines Underwriter
Matt Karch

As an associate who works remotely, I feel Integrity does a great job keeping me included which makes me feel like a valued team member.

Matt Karch
Sr. Workers’ Compensation Representative

We believe investing in associates is key to our success.

Our associates are happy and enjoy competitive compensation / benefits package,
career development opportunities and work-life balance.

And a catalog of great perks.

  1. Casual work environment
  2. Associate engagement opportunities
  1. Summer hours
  2. Paid time off to volunteer
  1. Associate referral incentive
  2. And more!

Career Development Opportunities

  1. Education assistance
  2. Licensing/certification
  3. Skill training
  4. Development plans
  5. Cross-functional development plans

Competitive pay and benefits

  1. Medical, dental and vision coverage
  2. Health savings account
  3. Flexible spending accounts
  4. Life insurance & disability benefits
  5. 10 paid holidays per year, plus paid time off
  6. 401(k) retirement plan
  7. Education reimbursement

Health and Wellness

We strive to promote a healthy work environment that improves the quality of life for our associates. Some of the benefits we offer include:

  1. Regularly scheduled group fitness classes (virtual and live)
  2. Columbus, OH fitness facility
  3. Fun, company-sponsored sporting activities like golf, volleyball, basketball and softball
  4. Dietitian, nurse and trainer available for consultations
  5. Weight management programs
  6. Wellness incentive program
  7. Annual wellness fair with health screenings

We’re proud to invest in communities throughout our three state footprint through financial, volunteerism and in-kind donations.

We’re proud to be a United Way Top 15 Most Generous Workplaces for three years running! We encourage associates to team up and get involved, as well as, provide them with opportunities to give back in the communities we serve.

In 2020, our various contributions with Grange Insurance totaled to:

  1. Nearly $2 million – Approximate donations to over 100 nonprofit organizations
  2. 50% of leadership – Served on local nonprofit boards
  3. More than 6,000 – Associate hours volunteered for various charities
  4. More than $17,000 – Worth of in-kind printing services for nonprofits
Collage of Integrity employee volunteer activities

Our mission to provide peace of mind and protection during life’s unexpected events goes beyond insurance. Learn how we deliver on our mission through community service.


Contact the Integrity recruiting team at IntegrityHR@imico.com or connect with us on LinkedIn.

Search for open positions