Pay online

Online bill pay is the easiest and quickest way to make payments.
  • Pay with electronic check, ATM debit card, credit or check card.
  • View your account balance and see when your next payment is due.
  • Set up automatic payments using Easy Pay® (EFT).
Log in to your account

Or, skip logging in:

Make a one-time payment

*Auto, Home and Business policy payments only


Pay by phone

Call the Integrity Billing Information System at (888) 699-9182.

* Auto, Home and Business policy payments only


Pay by mail

(Please include your policy number on your check)

Mail payments to:

Integrity Insurance Company
P.O. Box 88017
Chicago, IL 60680-1017

Mortgage billed payments:

Integrity Insurance Company 
P.O. Box 740604
Cincinnati, OH 45274-0604

Corporate headquarters:

Integrity Insurance Company 
2121 East Capitol Drive, P.O. Box 539 
Appleton, WI 54912-0539

Grange Life payments:

Grange Life Insurance Company
P.O. Box 740836
Cincinnati, OH 45274-0836


Questions?

Check out frequently asked questions for answers to some of the most common customer questions. If you still need help, call us at (888) 699-9182.