Meet our Integrity Insurance Leadership Team

Our leadership team is committed to growing our business and serving our policyholders, agents and community.



John Ammendola

President & CEO

Named president and CEO in late 2014 by the Grange Board of Directors, John Ammendola oversees the future development and growth of Grange Enterprise’s business, including operations of our partner company, Integrity Insurance. He joined the company in 2010 as president of personal lines and later assumed additional responsibility for the commercial lines business as chief property and casualty officer. With more than 30 years of insurance experience, he previously held a variety of leadership positions with Kemper Insurance, Safeco Insurance and GEICO.

Tim Cunningham

Chief Information Officer

In this role, Tim leads major technology investments across all lines of business with the goal of delivering excellent customer service through innovative solutions. An industry veteran, Tim has experience managing and implementing technology advancements across an organization to drive positive results. Prior to joining the company, he served more than 25 years with Bank One/JPMorgan Chase where he held several leadership roles, including serving as chief technology officer. Under his guidance, JPMorgan Chase successfully developed and deployed digital and mobile strategies.

Doreen DeLaney Crawley

Chief Operations Officer

Doreen DeLaney Crawley oversees all internal operations and delivers on the customer promise. She leads the company’s claims, billing, customer care, human resources, community impact and inclusive culture, real estate and operations teams. Doreen joined the company in 2010 after holding various senior leadership roles at Computer Sciences Corp., CNA Insurance and Countrywide’s Bank and Insurance companies.

Cheryl Lebens

Chief Financial Officer

Cheryl Lebens oversees Grange and Integrity’s financial management, risk management and investment portfolio, ensuring the company’s continued financial strength. With 30 years of experience in the insurance industry, Cheryl has held several key leadership roles, including President of Personal Lines and Vice President, Chief Risk and Strategy Officer. Before joining the company in 2012, she had leadership positions in finance, corporate strategy, sales and marketing at Nationwide Insurance and Safeco Insurance.

Ryan Michel

Chief Property & Casualty Officer

Ryan Michel leads Grange and Integrity’s property and casualty operations, overseeing P&C strategy with a focus on profitable growth across personal and commercial lines, risk management, operational excellence, product development, agency distribution and key transformational initiatives. With more than 20 years of experience, Ryan most recently served as president and chief underwriting officer at Trusted Resource Underwriters. Prior to that, he held various executive leadership roles at The Allstate Corporation in both the U.S. and Canada.

Beth Murphy

Chief Legal Officer

Beth Murphy serves as Corporate Secretary to the Board of Directors and oversees all corporate legal matters for Grange Enterprise including regulatory, governmental affairs, compliance, internal audit, and house counsel. In this role, she is responsible for the management of corporate litigation, oversight of specific business transactions between Grange and third parties and working to ensure the Grange Enterprise Companies maintain compliance with local, state, and federal regulations.


Integrity Insurance Company and Grange Insurance Company are part of the Grange Enterprise Companies. Together they bring the combined power of Integrity and Grange to our agents and customers across our 13-state footprint.