Our leadership team works tirelessly for you. Every day.

Jill Wagner Kelly

Jill Wagner Kelly

President

Jill was named President of Integrity Insurance in 2014. She leads Integrity's brand promise, company vision, strategy and annual operating goals and objectives. In addition, she serves on the Senior Leadership Team at Grange Insurance in Columbus, OH. With more than 25 years of experience in the insurance industry, she previously held a variety of leadership positions with SECURA Insurance and Acuity. Jill has a Bachelor of Business Administration and MBA from Lakeland University. She's active with NAMIC and serves on the Board of Directors for United Way, Big Brothers, Big Sisters of the Fox Valley, Prospera Credit Union.

Bobbie Collies

Bobbie Collies

VP, Sales & Marketing

As VP, Sales & Marketing, Bobbie leads the development and execution of sales and marketing strategies that address business needs to deliver profitable growth and enhancing Integrity's brand and relationships with independent insurance agents. She has a Bachelor of Business Administration in Marketing and Human Resources from the University of Wisconsin-Oshkosh and holds CIC and AIS insurance designations. Bobbie previously held leadership and commercial positions at SECURA Insurance and Society Insurance.

Sarah Krause

Sarah Krause

AVP, Talent Management & Operations; Interim PL Leader

As AVP – Talent Management & Operations, Sarah leads the design, implementation and management of all strategies and initiatives to enhance leadership capability at all levels, deepen bench strength, drive associate engagement and retention. She also oversees Human Resources, Support Services and Information Technology Services. As Interim PL Leader, she adds strength and momentum to our Personal Lines team as we continue to position ourselves for long-term profitable growth. Her knowledge of the independent agency channel is valuable as we focus on ease of doing business and digital innovation. Sarah has a Bachelor of Business Administration – Risk Management and Insurance from the University of Wisconsin – Madison, 20 plus years of industry and leadership experience and holds several insurance designations — CPCU, ARM, AU and ARe.

Andy Ott

Andy Ott

Interim Claims Leader

As Interim Claims Leader, Andy leads Integrity's claims operations and oversees the fulfillment of the financial and contractual obligation to customers and claimants who have sustained a loss. Andy has a Bachelor of Business Administration from the University of Wisconsin and MBA from the University of Wisconsin-Oshkosh. He brings nearly ten years of insurance management and leadership experience. In addition, he holds a CPCU designation.

Matt Sharp

Matt Sharp

AVP, Senior Finance Officer

As AVP, Senior Finance Officer, Matt is responsible for supporting profitable growth through financial insights and increasing financial knowledge for Integrity and Grange Commercial Lines. He has a degree in Mathematics from Wittenberg University in Springfield, OH. He is a Fellow of the Casualty Actuarial Society. He has 15 years of experience in actuarial roles at Grange Insurance and Nationwide Insurance. He's an active board member of Action for Children in Columbus, OH.

Dan Trochil

Dan Trochil

VP, Commercial Lines

As VP, Commercial Lines, Dan leads Integrity's commercial lines underwriting, operations and risk management functions and has full profit and loss responsibility. Dan holds a Bachelor of Business Administration with a double major in Finance and Marketing from the University of Iowa. He brings more than 10 years of insurance experience and previously held commercial roles at SECURA Insurance.