Doing more for our policyholders since 1933

Integrity Mutual Insurance Company was formed July 28, 1933, by Franklin C. Jesse, Sr. and Gordon Bubolz of the Home Mutual Insurance Company in Appleton, Wisconsin. They saw the need for a good farm mutual fire insurance company. Wisconsin needed a company that would do more for its policyholders than just write policies and collect premiums; a company that would offer sound protection for farmers and everyone else.

Today, we offer affordable and customizable auto, home, business and life insurance products. Together with Grange Insurance, our affiliate company located in Columbus, OH, we serve customers across 13 states and are committed to selling exclusively through independent agents.

Strength & stability

On December 19, 2001, Integrity Mutual Insurance Company entered an Affiliation Agreement with Grange Insurance Company of Columbus, Ohio. With the Affiliation, Integrity gained access to a wealth of resources Grange had to offer, including an A. M. Best rating of A (excellent), technology and training/development opportunities.

Superior, customer service

From a company focused on rural customers in its early days to one that promises to provide “insurance with integrity” for both personal and business needs, Integrity is focused on providing the kind of customer service that sets us apart in the marketplace.

We’re here to take care of our customers’ needs today and will be here for them tomorrow – and that’s our unwavering commitment. Insurance the way it should be – something we all value.