Mail a payment Please make checks payable to “Integrity Insurance Company” and include your policy number on the memo line. Life insurance Grange Insurance P.O. Box 740836 Cincinnati, OH 45274 Mortgage billed Integrity Insurance P.O. Box 740604 Cincinnati, OH 45274 All other insurance Integrity Insurance P.O. Box 88017 Chicago, IL 60680 Due date approaching? Send your overnight and express mail payments to: Grange Insurance 671 South High Street Columbus, OH 43206 Corporate mailing address Grange Insurance P.O. Box 1218 Columbus, OH 43216