Pay online Online bill pay is the easiest and quickest way to make payments. Pay with electronic check, ATM debit card, credit or check card. View your account balance and see when your next payment is due. Set up automatic payments using Easy Pay® (EFT). Enroll in Paperless Billing. Log in to your account Or, skip logging in: Make a one-time payment *Auto, Home and Business policy payments only Pay by phone Call the Integrity Billing Information System at (888) 699-9182. * Auto, Home and Business policy payments only Pay by mail (Please include your policy number on your check) Mail payments to: Integrity Insurance Company P.O. Box 88017 Chicago, IL 60680-1017 Mortgage billed payments: Integrity Insurance Company P.O. Box 740604 Cincinnati, OH 45274-0604 Corporate headquarters: Integrity Insurance Company 2121 East Capitol Drive, P.O. Box 539 Appleton, WI 54912-0539 Grange Life payments: Grange Life Insurance Company P.O. Box 740836 Cincinnati, OH 45274-0836 Questions? Check out frequently asked questions for answers to some of the most common customer questions. If you still need help, call us at (888) 699-9182.