Claims contacts

Call Integrity's Fraud Hotline at (800) 847-6332 to report suspicious activity about a claim. Our Special Investigations Unit will privately review the situation and determine if further investigation is warranted.

Assistant Regional Manager Auto Liability

Amy Warhurst (920) 968-8467

Claims AMD Manager

Rebecca Lewis (614) 593-7613

Auto Liability Claims Reps

Hillary Asante (920) 968-8377
Emily Biggie (920) 968-8455
Jess Brown (920) 968-8394
Abby Davis (614) 593-7647
Tyler Grovogel (920) 968-8389
Corey Hussey (920) 968-8376
Matt Peterson (920) 968-8388
Kalie Tracey (920) 968-8440
Alyx Vander Velden (920) 968-8315
Rob Ventgen (920) 968-8403
Harrison Zeman (920) 968-8390

Field Claims Property Manager

Laura Kraus (614) 449-5408

Property Claims Associates

Matt Jakubowski (920) 968-8451
Pete Kaul (920) 968-8313
Brenda Roh (920) 968-8391
Melisa Winkler (920) 968-8429

Claims Assistant

Sharon Friebel (920) 968-8361

Casualty Claims

Casualty Claims Rep Team Lead

Melissa Mueller (920) 968-8473

Sr. Casualty Claims Reps

Grant Crawford (920) 968-8319
Rick Getsfried (920) 968-8470

Casualty Claims Reps

Tessa Frost (920) 968-8358
April Pitzen (920) 968-8303
Brooke Segerstrom (920) 968-8489

Sr. Commercial Casualty Claims Associate

David Quigley (920) 968-8385

Commercial Casualty Claims Associate

Ryan Babb (920) 968-8405

Litigation Specialist

Kathryn Getty (920) 968-8396

Workers' Compensation Claims

Workers' Compensation Manager

Lisa Van Camp (920) 968-8407

Workers' Compensation Team Lead

Franklin Searer (920) 968-8402

Sr. Workers' Compensation Reps

Linda Frahm (920) 968-8397
Matt Karch (920) 968-8410
Tina Leverance (920) 968-8408
Stacy Perry (920) 968-8395
Lisa Walhof (920) 968-8432
Kendra Welton (920) 968-8379

Workers' Compensation Claims Reps

Sandy Daukus (614) 593-7643
Heather House (920) 968-8463

Workers' Compensation Support Reps

Macy Dudley (920) 968-8347
Laurie Hoffman (920) 968-8349